Oneofthemostinterestingquestionsaboutgulliverstravelsiswhetherthehouyhnhnmsrepresentanidealofrationalityorwhetherontheotherhandtheyarethebuttofswift39;ssatire。inotherwords,inbookiv,isswiftpokingfunatthetalkinghorsesordoesheintendforustotakethemseriouslyastheproperwaytoact?Ifwelookcloselyatthewaythatthehouyhnhnmsact,wecanseethatinfactswiftdoesnottakethemseriously:heusesthemtoshowthedangersofpride。 Firstwehavetoseethatswiftdoesnoteventakegullverseriously。forinstance,hisnamesoundsmuchlikegullible,whichsuggeststhathewillbelieveanything。also,whenhefirstseestheyahoosandtheythrowexcrementonhim,herespondsbydoingthesameinreturnuntiltheyrunaway。Hesays,Imustneedsdiscoversomemorerationalbeing,eventhoughasahumanheisalreadythemostrationalbeingthereis。Thisiswhyswiftreferstoerasmusdarwinsdiscoveryoftheoriginofthespeciesandthevoyageofthebeagletoshowhowgulliverknowsthatpeopleareatthetopofthefoodchain。Butiflemulegulliverissatirized,soarethehouyhnhnms,whosevoicessoundlikethecallofcastrati。 Theywalkontwolegsinsteadoffour,andseemtobemuchlikepeople。Asgulliversays,itwaswiththeutmostastonishmentthatIwitnessedthesecreaturesplayingthefluteanddancingavienesewaltz。Tomymind,theyseemedlikethegreatesthumanseverseenincourt,evenmoredextrousthanthelordedmundburke。Asthisquotedemonstrates,gulliveristerriblyimpressed,buthisadmirationforthehouyhnhnmsisshortlivedbecausetheyaresoprideful。Forinstance,theleaderofthehouyhnhnmsclaimsthathehasreadalltheworksofcharlesdickens,andthathecansinglehandedlyrecitethenamesofallthekingsandqueensofenglanduptogeorgeii。Swiftsubtlyshowsthatthishouyhnhnmsprideismisplacedwhen,inthemiddleoftheintellectualcompetition,heforgetsthenameofqueenelizabethshusband。 Swiftssatireofthehouyhnhnmscomesoutinotherwaysaswell。Oneofthemostmemorablescenesiswhenthedapplegreymareattemptstowoothehorsethatguenivrehasbroughtwithhimtotheisland。firstsheactsflirtatiously,paradingaroundthebewilderedhorse。Butwhenthisdoesnothavethedesiredeffect,shegetsanotheridea:asIwatchedinamazementfrommyperchinthetopofatree,thesorrelnagdashedoffandreturnedwithayahooonherbackwhowasyetmoremonstrousthanmr。Popebeingfittedbyaclothier。Shedroppedthiscreaturebeforemynagasifofferingupasacrifice。Myhorsesniffedthecreatureandturnedaway。 Itmightseemthatweshouldtakethissceneseriouslyasafailedattemptatcourtship,andthatconsequentlyweshouldseethegreymareasanunrequitedlover。Butitmakesmoresenseifweseethatswiftisbeingsatirichere:Itisthefemalehouyhnhnmwhomakesthemove,whichwouldnothavehappenedineighteenthcenturyengland。thehouyhnhmisbeingprideful,anditisthatpridethatmakeshimunabletoimpressgullivershorse。gulliverimaginesthehorsesaying,sblood,thenotionofcreatingthebarebackedbeastwithananimalwhohadheldmr。Popeonherbackmakesmequeezy。 Afinalindicationthatthehouyhnmnsarenotmeanttobetakenseriouslyoccurswhentheleaderofthehouynhmsvisitslilliput,wherehevisitsthefrenchroyalsociety。Hegoesintoaroominwhichascientististryingtoturnwineintowater(itselfapridefulactthatreferstothemarriageatgallilee)。 Thescientisthasbeenworkinghardattheexperimentformanyyearswithoutsuccess,whenthehouyhnmnarrivesandimmediatelyknowsthattodo:thecreaturenosoonersteppedthroughthedoorwaythanhestruckuponaplan。slurpingupallthewineinsight,hequicklymadewaterinabucketthatsatnearthedoor。 Hehasaccomplishedthescientistsgoal,butthescientistisnothappy,forhislivelihoodhasnowbeendestroyed。Swiftsclearimplicationisthateventhoughthehouyhnhmnsaresmart,theydonotknowhowtousethatknowledgeforthebenefitofsociety,onlyfortheirownpridefulagrandizement。 Throughoutgulliverstravels,thehouyhnhmsareshowntobeanidealgonewrong。Thoughtheirintentmighthavebeengood,theydon39;tknowhowtodowhattheywanttodobecausetheyarefilledwithpride。Theymisleadgulliverandtheyevenmisleadthemselves。Thesatireonthemisparticularlywellexplainedbythenewbornhouyhnhmwho,havingjustbeenborn,exclaims,withthissortofentrance,whatmustIexpectfromtherestofmylife!